Category: Upcoming Legislation

  • Will Congress Extend the Estate Tax Amnesty? What Heirs Face

    Will Congress Extend the Estate Tax Amnesty? What Heirs Face

    “The goal is not to excuse permanent noncompliance. It is to make compliance possible, so property can pass to the surviving heirs and be used responsibly.”

    – Atty. Ernesto C. Perez II, CTEP
    Vintage property documents tied with twine, an old key and family photographs on a wooden table, with a house visible through the window and text reading “Estate Tax Amnesty Extension By Christmas?”

    By Realttorney®

    My humble opinion: Congress should forthwith enact a further extension of a time-limited Estate Tax Amnesty until December 31, 2028. The amnesty extension would not erase the basic estate tax. Heirs would still pay it, but the enormous relief from accumulated surcharges, interest, and penalties would make settlement and eventual transfer of inherited property more attainable.

    What is the Estate Tax Amnesty, and where does it stand today?

    The Estate Tax Amnesty is a time-limited program that lets the estate of a deceased person settle unpaid estate tax at a reduced, fixed cost and obtain relief from related surcharges, interest, and penalties, subject to the statute’s requirements.

    The most recently enacted extension, Republic Act No. 11956, allowed filing and payment from June 15, 2023 to June 14, 2025, for estates of decedents who died on or before May 31, 2022. The BIR’s later circular refers to June 16, 2025, as the final filing date. That period has ended. As of November 11, 2026, the Senate of the Philippines is crafting another extension.

    The House of Representatives approved House Bill No. 6614 in December 2025 and transmitted it to the Senate on December 17, 2025. The Senate Committee on Ways and Means, chaired by Sen. Panfilo Lacson, took up the measures on October 23, 2026. The Senate filed fourteen (14) estate tax bills in the 20th Congress. As transmitted to the Senate, House Bill No. 6614 would cover estates of decedents who died on or before December 31, 2024, and extend availment to December 31, 2028.

    Up for debate is the coverage and deadline of the estate tax amnesty availment because the different Senate bills propose different coverages and deadlines for when the benefits will expire.

    Why should heirs be given more time to settle inherited property?

    An old Torrens title can tell a familiar story: the registered owner died long ago, but the property remains in that person’s name. The heirs may know who should inherit it, yet the legal steps and payment of estate tax were never completed. When one generation passes without settling the estate, the next inherits both the land and the unfinished work, and its concomitant complications.

    That is why a defined procedure and period of availment matter. Families need a workable path to pay the basic tax, resolve festering documentation problems, and proceed with the formal transfer to the surviving heirs.

    On November 11, 2026, I wrote a letter to Senate President Gatchalian stating my full support for the December 31, 2028 deadline, as proposed in House Bill No. 6614 passed by the House of Representatives last year. Moreover, House Bill No. 6614 proposed a December 31, 2024 death-date cutoff. The Department of Finance (DOF), in its December 9, 2025 statement supporting the bill, described a different cutoff of May 31, 2022, and Senate Bill No. 1889 proposes yet another, December 31, 2025.

    What did the previous amnesty periods collect?

    As reported on October 23, 2026, the DOF said the amnesty program had collected ₱16.13 billion from about 330,000 successful applications since 2019. The figures show real revenue and encouraging participation in the amnesty program.

    But the data do not show how many parcels of land were actually transferred. A count of applications is not a count of estates whose settlement and title transfer were completed. Lawmakers should not treat one as proof of the other. Nor do past collections prove what a future extension would collect.

    Is an amnesty application the same as a completed land transfer?

    No. Paying the amnesty tax settles the tax. Transferring title is a separate process. A Certificate Authorizing Registration (eCAR) is the BIR document the Registry of Deeds requires before it will register a transfer of real estate to the beneficiaries.

    The Bureau of Internal Revenue’s Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 33-2026, issued April 27, 2026, says there is no deadline to submit proof of estate settlement, such as an extrajudicial settlement or a court order. Please note that not submitting such a document by the June 16, 2025 deadline does not invalidate an amnesty application. The same circular says the proof is required for processing and issuing the eCAR, which is necessary for transferring the estate’s assets. A renewed program should say clearly which documents are needed to avail and which may follow before the eCAR is issued.

    This is why lawmakers should ask the BIR to report more than applications and overall collections. The BIR should also report how many eCARs were issued in connection with the availment of previous estate tax amnesties to get a better picture of the full and complete process.

    What do heirs encounter in actual estate-settlement work?

    In my practice, the difficulty often multiplies when an estate has stayed unsettled for several generations. Since 2018, our office has handled or advised on more than one hundred estate-settlement transactions. Most matters settled under earlier amnesties involved multiple generations of unsettled estates. The family is not dealing with one death and one set of papers. The settlement of the estate of the deceased registered owner indicated on the land title may involve a chain of succession that began with the failure to settle the primary estate.

    Old civil-registry records are another obstacle. In matters involving registered owners who died in 1956 or earlier, heirs often cannot obtain PSA-certified birth or marriage certificates from 60 to 70 years ago. I have not kept case-by-case statistics that would let me rank this against lack of funds or other causes of nonpayment, but it recurs in my work and deserves attention when lawmakers design proof requirements.

    The Senate hearing raised the same tension. Sen. Lacson warned that delays in getting documents from the Philippine Statistics Authority could consume the proposed 15- to 20-day processing period. The hearing also discussed barangay certifications used in place of death certificates in remote areas, and the risk of fake deaths for inheritance. Both concerns are real. Hence, adequate rules should work for heirs with genuinely old records and be careful enough to prevent fraud.

    Why not simply collect the tax and all accumulated charges?

    The government has a legitimate interest in collecting estate tax. The better question is whether the public interest is served by collecting the basic tax under a defined relief program, or by letting surcharges, interest, and penalties accumulate while families remain unable to settle and transfer the property.

    Many heirs are asset-rich but cash-poor: the main asset is land, and the family lacks cash for the tax and accumulated charges. A deadline alone may not solve that concern. Installment terms can help if they are clear, completed within the statutory period, and carry stated consequences for default. Under the previous program, RMC No. 33-2026 allowed installments within two years without civil penalty and interest, with prior approval from the Revenue District Office. A missed installment was treated as forfeiture of the amnesty availment.

    A settled estate may also be better positioned for lease, sale, partition, development, or use as collateral. These are possible uses, not guaranteed outcomes. Hence, an amnesty program cannot resolve every title defect, family dispute, unpaid local tax, or registration issue. But it can remove one important barrier.

    What about the concern that repeated amnesties teach people to wait?

    The concern is serious. At the October 23 hearing, DepDev Assistant Secretary Reynaldo Cancio warned that frequent amnesties may lead taxpayers to expect more and reduce revenues. Senate President Sherwin Gatchalian asked the DOF to study whether the 6% rate is still too expensive, given three amnesties since 2019, and why many families still cannot pay.

    A further extension should therefore have a clear statutory sunset, be announced as a defined opportunity, and come with a public commitment to ordinary compliance and enforcement once the window closes. Congress cannot bind a future Congress, but it can avoid presenting relief as automatic.

    Financial hardship is a credible barrier, but documentation problems, processing time, lack of awareness, and complicated succession may also contribute. I do not claim lack of money is the main cause in every case. The DOF should publish a root-cause analysis, and the BIR should report how often applications are delayed or rejected, and why.

    What should a further extension include?

    1. A firm deadline and clear cutoff. Set December 31, 2028, and state the eligible death-date cutoff in the statute.
    2. Clear installment rules for families who cannot pay at once.
    3. Clear document rules. Enumerate which documents are needed to avail and which may follow before the eCAR, with reliable alternative proof for genuinely unavailable historical records and safeguards against fictitious claims.
    4. Public reporting. Require the BIR to publish periodic figures on applications, collections, eCAR issuance, transfer outcomes, and common barriers.

    The various legislative proposals pending before the Senate do not agree on coverage or the period of availment. House Bill No. 6614, as transmitted to the Senate, covers deaths on or before December 31, 2024, and allows installments within two years, with an initial payment of at least 25%. Sen. Lacson’s Senate Bill No. 1889 is a standalone measure that would cover deaths on or before December 31, 2025, at a uniform 6% of the net estate. Most other Senate bills are understood to amend the existing law, Republic Act No. 11213, mainly to extend the availment period. I am confident that the final law would settle these differences for the proper guidance of the families, BIR, and other concerned government agencies, both local and national.

    What should heirs, owners, and brokers do while the extension is pending?

    Treat the extension as a proposal, not a promise. No deadline exists today, and no one should rely on a date that Congress has not enacted. (This is practice guidance, not a legal requirement.)

    Heirs and owners can still prepare. Whatever the enrolled bill says, the BIR requires proof of estate settlement, such as an extrajudicial settlement or a court order, before it issues the eCAR. Gathering civil-registry records and title documents now, and starting any settlement that needs to be done anyway, shortens the path later.

    Brokers and salespersons should tell clients plainly where the measure stands, and determine whether to delay a sale or conveyance of a real estate involving an unsettled estate or proceed with the transaction despite the pendency of the bills at the Senate at this time.

    Frequently asked questions

    Does an estate tax amnesty mean heirs do not have to pay estate tax?

    No. Under the previous program, estates paid an estate amnesty tax of 6%, as the BIR’s Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 33-2026 illustrates. Terms of any new extension must come from the law Congress enacts. An extension is still being considered by our Senators.

    How many estates were fully settled under the previous amnesties?

    No verified figure exists. The DOF reported about 330,000 successful applications, which is a count of applications, not of completed settlements and title transfers. The BIR requires proof of estate settlement before issuing an eCAR.

    Why can inherited land stay in a deceased relative’s name for decades?

    Unpaid estate tax and accumulated charges, missing civil-registry records, several generations of unsettled estates, family dynamics, and other legal or administrative requirements can all delay transfer to the designated beneficiaries. Their relative weight should be established with government data and should never be assumed.

    Is the Estate Tax Amnesty open right now?

    No. The period under Republic Act No. 11956 ended on June 14, 2025, and no further extension had been enacted as of November 11, 2026.

    A defined opportunity to regularize inherited property

    The previous estate tax amnesty has produced measurable collections and wide participation. To reiterate, an application count is not a land-transfer count, and repeated extensions raise fair questions about compliance. A carefully designed extension to December 31, 2028 can answer both sides: collect the basic estate tax, give eligible heirs a realistic route through old tax and documentation barriers, set a firm sunset, guard against abuse, and require public reporting.

    The goal is not to excuse permanent noncompliance. It is to make compliance possible, so property can pass to the surviving heirs and be used responsibly.

    If you are an heir or property owner with an unsettled estate, or a broker or salesperson with clients waiting on the extension, consider booking a consultation with Realttorney® to sort out which documents, taxes, and steps apply to the facts.


    This article is for general information and educational purposes. It is not a substitute for legal advice based on the facts and documents of a particular estate.

    About the Author

    Atty. Jojo Perez is a real estate and estate planning attorney, a licensed real estate broker, and a PRC‑accredited lecturer and speaker on real estate topics. Through Realttorney®, he helps property owners, borrowers, and real estate professionals understand the legal principles and practical considerations involved in property ownership, foreclosure, and real estate transactions in the Philippines.

  • Condo Nearing 50 Years? Your Rights in the Philippines

    Condo Nearing 50 Years? Your Rights in the Philippines

    Part 1 of a three-part series

    “We shape our buildings and afterwards our buildings shape us.”

    — Winston Churchill, House of Commons, 28 October 1943
    An older Filipino couple looks through their condominium window toward an aging residential building.
    AI-generated illustration.

    By Realttorney®

    “My condominium building is approaching 50 years old. What happens to my unit?”

    Your ownership does not automatically expire when the building reaches 50 years. But continued ownership brings a practical question: what should owners do when the building needs substantial repairs, becomes expensive to maintain, or may be better replaced?

    The answer requires separating three things: your property interest, the life of the condominium corporation, and the condition of the building. These are connected, but they are not interchangeable.

    A corporation may have perpetual existence. Concrete, pipes, elevators, and electrical systems still require maintenance. The Revised Corporation Code can provide continuity for the condominium corporation, but it cannot repair or maintain the building and its systems.

    Perpetual corporate existence does not establish the building’s useful life

    Section 11 of the Revised Corporation Code, R.A. 11232, makes perpetual existence the general rule unless the articles of incorporation provide otherwise. It also addresses qualifying corporations incorporated before the Code took effect.

    For condominium corporations, however, there is a special provision to read alongside that general rule. Section 11 of the Condominium Act, R.A. 4726, ties the corporation’s term to the duration of the condominium project, notwithstanding the Corporation Law.

    Even before the Revised Corporation Code, therefore, the Condominium Act did not prescribe an automatic 50-year expiry for every condominium corporation.

    The practical concern is the building’s continued suitability, safety, and economic usefulness. Age is a reason to investigate those matters. It is not a substitute for investigating them.

    A well-maintained older project and a poorly maintained younger project may present very different problems. Neither the year on a completion document nor the paint on the lobby walls answers every question.

    What exactly do you own?

    Section 2 of R.A. 4726 describes a condominium as a separate interest in a unit together with an undivided interest, directly or indirectly, in the land and other common areas. The common areas may be held through a specially formed condominium corporation.

    Your condominium therefore involves more than the space behind your front door. The title, master deed, declaration of restrictions, and corporate documents help explain the nature and extent of your rights.

    That distinction becomes particularly important when owners discuss selling the project or replacing the building. Selling common areas, selling everybody’s separate units, and dissolving the corporation involve different legal questions.

    Before agreeing to any proposal, establish which transaction is actually being proposed. A presentation labelled “redevelopment” may leave unanswered whether you are being asked to sell, contribute your property to a venture, or exchange it for promised future benefits.

    What does the existing 50-year provision actually say?

    Section 8(c) of R.A. 4726 provides a ground for judicial partition by sale when the following circumstances exist together:

    1. The project has existed in excess of 50 years.
    2. It is obsolete and uneconomic.
    3. Owners holding, in aggregate, more than 50% interest in the common areas oppose repair, restoration, remodeling, or modernization.

    These are cumulative requirements for that particular ground. The wording is not simply “the building is 50 years old.”

    Section 13(c) contains a corresponding ground concerning dissolution of a condominium corporation, with its own description of the relevant member or stockholder interests. Source: R.A. 4726, Sections 8 and 13.

    Economic obsolescence also deserves careful treatment. A building may remain physically usable while its costs and limitations make continued operation less attractive. Conversely, a proposal offering greater development value does not, by itself, establish structural danger.

    For an actual project, legal analysis should be informed by competent technical findings and financial information. An attractive offer from a developer is an offer. It is not an engineering report.

    Can an entire project already be sold without everyone agreeing?

    Existing law already recognizes routes for partition or dissolution in specified circumstances. Sections 8 and 13 address serious damage, failure to rebuild, obsolescence, condemnation or expropriation, and conditions in the registered declaration of restrictions.

    Section 14 separately provides an additional voluntary-dissolution route requiring the affirmative vote of all stockholders or members at a meeting duly called for that purpose, together with statutory compliance.

    This is why saying “redevelopment always requires unanimity under existing law” is too broad. One must first identify the legal route and satisfy its requirements.

    There is another frequently overlooked provision. R.A. 7899, enacted in 1995, already amended Sections 4 and 16. Section 16 now permits specified dispositions of common areas with simple-majority authorization of registered owners and prior notification to all registered owners.

    That authority should not be casually treated as permission to sell every owner’s separate unit. Similarly, the master-deed amendment mechanism in Section 4 has its own voting basis, notification, approval, and registration requirements.

    The details matter because the legal object of each decision is different.

    What would the Condominium Redevelopment Act change?

    This proposed law seeks to make collective decisions concerning aging projects more workable. The principal measures discussed in Congress are House Bill No. 2286 and Senate Bill No. 2420.

    The official House Committee Report No. 12, containing HB 2286, proposes the following age-based changes to Section 14:

    Project ageProposed approval under the reviewed House text
    At least 30 years but less than 50 yearsTwo-thirds of stockholders or members
    At least 50 yearsSimple majority of stockholders or members

    The House text also requires compliance with Title XIV of the Revised Corporation Code and refers to Section 4 for determining owners’ votes.

    Notice the difference: existing Section 8(c) uses in excess of 50 years, together with additional conditions. The proposed Section 14 route uses 50 years or more for its lower voting threshold. They should not be merged into one rule.

    The House committee version also contains a drafting issue for projects younger than 30: its replacement Section 14 does not expressly state their threshold. Later government reporting on the Senate-approved measure describes unanimous approval by members in good standing for that category.

    The original Senate Bill No. 235 proposed different thresholds again. An investor should therefore ask which version a speaker, article, or sales presentation is relying upon. Source: original SB 235.

    Has the proposal become an effective law?

    As of November 12, 2026, the sources reviewed establish congressional approval of the bicameral conference committee report. Senator Escudero’s November 11 update confirms Senate third-reading approval and bicameral ratification.

    However, this article’s research has not verified the complete enrolled text, presidential receipt or action, or publication and effectivity of a resulting Republic Act.

    Accordingly, the thresholds above describe the identified proposal. They should not be presented as operative rules authorizing a transaction today. Before acting, obtain the final applicable instrument and verify its status.

    This qualification is particularly important because later versions may change provisions that appeared in the original bills.

    Does redevelopment guarantee another unit or a windfall?

    Neither age nor redevelopment discussion guarantees a profitable exit.

    Existing Section 15 provides a default mechanism, subject to the declaration of restrictions, for liquidation through sale of the entire project after qualifying voluntary dissolution. It expressly recognizes the rights of corporate and individual condominium creditors.

    The reviewed House proposal adds advance payment against an owner’s proportionate share of sale proceeds, based on the agreed valuation. The sponsor’s October 9 bicameral announcement describes whole-project sale and liquidating dividends as two liquidation options.

    Those provisions should not be read as an automatic promise of a replacement unit. A promised new unit, temporary housing, moving allowance, or share in future profits needs a clear and enforceable basis in the applicable arrangement.

    Ask what you will receive, when you will receive it, what liabilities must first be settled, and what happens if the buyer or developer fails to perform. The project’s selling price and your eventual net recovery are different figures.

    In Practice: a hypothetical 49-year-old condominium

    Suppose you own a unit in a project approaching its fiftieth year. Another owner says a developer will soon buy the building and everyone will receive a brand-new unit.

    Before making plans for your new kitchen, request the official proposal from the developer.

    Has the developer made a binding offer? Who commissioned the valuation? Are payments in cash, replacement property, or a combination? What approvals are required? Are there mortgages or unpaid project liabilities? When must residents vacate?

    Then examine the building’s actual condition. Would rehabilitation provide a reasonable alternative? What do the technical reports and financial records show?

    The fiftieth anniversary answers none of those questions by itself.

    Professional’s Take

    My recommendation is to treat an aging condominium as a shared property decision requiring legal, technical, and financial due diligence.

    Owners should request the governing documents, recent financial statements, available technical assessments, and any written collective-sale or redevelopment proposal. Practitioners should explain the applicable route and voting requirements before clients commit themselves.

    Perpetual corporate existence does not guarantee perpetual structural fitness. Equally, an older building does not automatically extinguish the property rights of its owners.

    The useful question is the one we started with: What happens to my unit? The answer depends on the project’s condition, the applicable law, the governing documents, and the transaction owners lawfully approve.

    In Part 2, we will examine what owners and prospective buyers should check before holding, buying, selling, or agreeing to redevelopment of an aging condominium.

    If your building is nearing 50 years, start by asking management for the documents supporting its condition and any proposed redevelopment. Decisions become easier to assess when the facts are on the table.


    About the Author

    Atty. Jojo Perez is a real estate and estate planning attorney, a licensed real estate broker, and a PRC‑accredited lecturer and speaker on real estate topics. Through Realttorney®, he helps property owners, borrowers, and real estate professionals understand the legal principles and practical considerations involved in property ownership, foreclosure, and real estate transactions in the Philippines.

  • The 99-Year Lease Debate: Implications for Real Estate and Other Looming Risks

    (Part 2 of 2)

    By Realttorney®

    Despite the passage of the “99-Year Lease Law” on third and final reading by both Houses of Congress on December 24, 2024, there is a chance that it will not become law in the next 6 months. After the May 2025 elections, it seems our legislators may have no appetite to push for the harmonization of the 2 versions of the bill in the bicameral conference, and the subsequent ratification of the approved version by both chambers of the Congress of the Philippines.

    While the proposal to amend Republic Act No. 7652 to extend the lease term for foreign investors to 99 years aims to attract more foreign capital and boost economic growth, it has generated several arguments against its enactment into law. Let us discuss some of these criticisms here.

    This is an opportune time for all real estate stakeholders to learn about the various risks and challenges if the proposed amendments become law. And, by the end of the article, we shall discuss the key takeaways for real estate service practitioners as they practice and serve valued clients in their chosen profession.

    As discussed in the previous article, the proposed amendments to Rep. Act No. 7652 seem constitutionally sound. However, critics argue that a 99-year lease is practically equivalent to foreign ownership of land, which is prohibited under the Philippine Constitution to protect national patrimony. Cause-oriented groups fear this could create loopholes allowing foreigners and foreign-owned entities to gain excessive control over the country’s land and resources over an extended period.

    In addition, detractors of the “99-Year Lease Law” view this 99-year lease contract as a multi-generational lease, far exceeding the average global life expectancy. As such, this long duration raises concerns about the potential for foreigners and foreign-owned entities to establish long-lasting dominance over strategic lands all over the Philippines.

    Furthermore, the extended security over private lands provided to foreign investors may create an uneven competitive landscape. Local enterprises may face challenges competing with foreign investors who have greater incentives and long-term stability in land access. This imbalance could hinder the growth and success of local businesses in the real estate sector.

    Hence, while the extension of a lease up to an aggregate period of 99 years may bring opportunities for growth and development in the real estate market, it is crucial to carefully consider and address the potential challenges and risks associated with this incentive. Therefore, we should understand the risks and learn how to mitigate them so that the real estate sector can continue to thrive and contribute positively to the Philippine economy.

    What are the potential challenges facing the real estate sector if Rep. Act No. 7652 is successfully amended?

    One major concern is the reduced availability of private land for domestic use. Long-term leases effectively take land out of circulation for nearly a century, which could worsen the scarcity of prime land in urban and highly industrialized areas. This scarcity may drive up costs for local businesses and residents, impacting the overall economic landscape.

    The passage of this law will impact the housing market, especially the socialized, low-cost to mid-market housing projects, in a negative way. Apart from the issue of affordability of such housing units, the passage of the “99-Year Lease Law” will drastically affect the supply of such housing projects, thereby exacerbating the ability of government to provide decent and affordable housing units to the low-income Filipinos.

    In addition, there is apprehension that the extended lease terms could lead to increased land values, potentially displacing local investors or developers and making it harder for Filipinos to afford land and housing in their own country.

    What are the potential negative impacts on agriculture and the local communities tied to agriculture?

    Socio-civic organizations have raised concerns that agricultural lands awarded to agrarian reform beneficiaries (ARBs) could be targeted for long-term lease for 99 years by foreign investors or foreign-owned entities. If so, this will undermine the goals of land redistribution and, most importantly, food security.

    Therefore, this amendatory bill, if signed into law, could lead to the expansion of large-scale agribusinesses controlled by foreign corporations, to the detriment of small-scale farmers and other local food producers in the Philippines.

    Historically, the government’s Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program (CARP) is designed to ensure the fair distribution of land to farmers and enhance agricultural productivity. The proposed amendments to the Investor’s Lease Act include provisions that require leases to adhere to agrarian reform laws.

    However, there are several concerns that need to be addressed. First, the detractors of the amendments see a potential risk that foreign investors may attempt to convert agricultural lands for industrial or commercial purposes. In their view, this could reduce the amount of land available for agrarian reform beneficiaries and jeopardize the long-term sustainability of the agricultural sector.

    But we have to remember that there are certain safeguards included in the amendments that would hopefully prevent these things from happening. If such eventualities happen, then it would not be the failure of the letter of the law and its implementing rules and regulations, but due to the weakness of the character of those implementing the agrarian reform law and the implementing agencies of the amendatory law.

    Second, and this is my opinion, enacting these amendments into law without the overall framework of a National Land Use Plan would present great regulatory challenges for the government regulators to manage and plan the use of land that is best for the Philippines, its regions, provinces, and cities.

    Without a comprehensive land use plan, each local government unit (LGU) will compete for the setting up of investment projects in their localities while sacrificing the need for human settlements, food production, and the protection of the environment and ancestral domains, if any, within their territorial jurisdiction.

    Monitoring and enforcing compliance of land use regulations of each LGU will be fragmented at best and may place a strain on government resources. Without effective oversight, there is a possibility of exploitation or non-compliance with the objectives of the Investor’s Lease Act, the laws on the environment, agrarian reform and other regulations.

    Furthermore, critics worry that the bill’s definition of “private lands” might be vague enough to include ancestral domains, putting these lands at risk of being leased to foreign investors and eroding the heritage and identity of indigenous communities. But of course, Rep. Act No. 8371 (the Indigenous Peoples’ Rights Act) will hopefully provide adequate protection and safeguards to the Indigenous Peoples’ Ancestral Domains.

    On a positive note, the proposed amendments to the Investor’s Lease Act could attract foreign investments in agro-industrial ventures. This could lead to increased employment opportunities for farmers and the introduction of modern agricultural technologies for the use of Filipino farmers.

    Thus, while the government’s land reform program has the potential to bring about positive changes in the agricultural sector, it is crucial to address the aforementioned concerns to ensure all stakeholders in the agricultural sector benefit from all foreign investments in agriculture and agro-industrial ventures.

    Economic Dependency and Lack of Real Impact: Some argue that such a long lease term could lead to economic dependence on foreign-owned entities, with control over significant land areas potentially shifting to foreign interests. Moreover, analysts suggest that the length of the land lease might not be the primary deterrent to foreign investment in the Philippines. Other factors like expensive power, poor infrastructure, governance issues, and graft and corruption might be more significant constraints. Therefore, extending the lease term alone might not guarantee a substantial increase in foreign investment or long-term economic development.

    What then are the key takeaways for Real Estate Service Practitioners?

    The proposed amendments to the Investor’s Lease Act could bring forth a myriad of challenges and opportunities for real estate service practitioners (RESPs) and real estate investors and developers.

    The first thing to keep in mind is the possible rise in demand for advisory services for RESPs. With lease terms being extended, foreign investors will seek expert guidance to navigate local laws and ensure the legality and sustainability of their lease agreements.

    Second, the increase in foreign direct investments in the Philippines may lead to an increase in demand for medium-scale or large-scale property development projects, opening doors for local partnerships and joint ventures for the clients of RESPs or the RESPs themselves.

    Third, the possible growing demand for real estate projects will necessitate that RESPs conduct thorough due diligence to guarantee that leased properties adhere to agrarian reform laws and local zoning ordinances, among others.

    Finally, it is imperative for RESPs to play a role in advocating for policies that strike a balance between protecting national interests and fostering economic growth. Ultimately, RESPs must be agents of positive change for all stakeholders in the real estate industry.

    RESPs must be prepared to adapt to the changes brought about by the forthcoming amendments to the Investor’s Lease Act and seize the opportunities it presents. By staying informed and proactive, RESPs can navigate the evolving landscape of the real estate industry with confidence and success.

    In conclusion, the proposed amendments to the Investor’s Lease Act demonstrate the government’s dedication to attracting foreign direct investments. While the proposed 99-year lease period is constitutionally acceptable, it is crucial to consider the potential drawbacks, such as impacts on land availability, the real estate market, and the land reform program, among others.

    To ensure that this policy achieves its objectives without compromising national interests, it is essential to establish robust safeguards, clear regulations, and transparent implementation by government officials. For professionals in the real estate industry, this development highlights the importance of staying informed and proactive in guiding clients through the changing legal landscape.

    Whether assisting foreign investors or safeguarding the rights of Filipino landowners, the real estate sector must serve as a conduit between opportunity and compliance. While proponents argue that a 99-year lease term will attract foreign investment and stimulate the economy, opponents voice significant concerns regarding national sovereignty, potential displacement of local communities, negative impacts on agriculture, questionable economic benefits, and potential legal complexities.

    The stakeholders in the real estate industry, especially RESPs, should urge Congress and the Executive Department to exercise caution and prioritize the long-term interests of Filipino citizens and national patrimony.

    Do you have anything to add? Or do you disagree with what we have written? Your comments will be very much welcomed.

    ——-

    Atty. Jojo is a real estate attorney, an estate planning attorney, a licensed real estate broker, and a PRC-accredited Lecturer/ Speaker for Training Programs in Real Estate. He is committed to helping new and veteran real estate service practitioners be well-informed of the latest laws, rules, regulations, and information relevant to the real estate service sector.

  • Amending the Right-of-Way Act with ARROW

    “On this note, the prevailing rule is that the courts will compel the establishment of a right of way only when absolutely necessary.”

    – Mr. Justice Gaerlan, Ponente in Sps. Vargas v. Sta. Lucia Realty and Development, Inc.

    By Realttorney®

    One of the most persistent challenges in the Philippines in terms of infrastructure development and projects has been the acquisition of land for right-of-way (ROW). This critical process has historically been beset by delays, inconsistencies, and legal hurdles, impeding the timely implementation of national and local development projects.

    Republic Act No. 10752, or “The Right-of-Way Act,” was passed in 2016 to streamline the land acquisition process for government infrastructure. However, as infrastructure ambitions grow in scale and complexity – particularly under the Build, Build, Build and its successor programs – the need for further reform has become evident.

    The proposed Senate Bill No. 2821, also known as the “Accelerated and Reformed Right-of-Way (ARROW) Act,” seeks to comprehensively amend Rep. Act No. 10752 to introduce more efficient, inclusive, and transparent processes concerning land acquisition for infrastructure projects by both the national government and public service providers. This blog explores the salient features of the ARROW Act, the motivations behind its reforms, and the implications for stakeholders in both the public and private sectors.

    Let’s begin.

    Rep. Act No. 10752 was enacted in 2016 to facilitate the acquisition of ROW for government infrastructure projects through streamlined procedures for negotiated sale and expropriation. Key features included payment of just compensation based on current market value, the inclusion of informal settlers in the compensation scheme, and a limited scope of coverage focusing primarily on government-led projects.

    However, the law fell short in addressing delays caused by valuation disputes, overlapping land claims, inconsistent property assessments, and lack of integration with private-sector infrastructure initiatives. These gaps hindered the government’s ability to implement infrastructure projects on time and within budget.

    Senate Bill No. 2821 is the committee report combining three Senate Bills, taking consideration House Bill No. 6571, and was filed on September 11, 2024. It proposes substantial amendments to Rep. Act No. 10752. It expands the law’s scope, introduces new mechanisms for planning and execution, and integrates the role of private entities providing public services.

    These reforms aim to accelerate and streamline the process of acquiring the necessary right-of-way. One of the major reforms the ARROW Act seeks to introduce is the expansion of the coverage of the law.

    Expanded Coverage. The ARROW Act explicitly broadens the application of the law to include all national government infrastructure projects undertaken through Public-Private Partnerships (PPP), referencing Republic Act No. 11966 or the “Public-Private Partnership (PPP) Code of the Philippines”.

    The coverage of the law now includes private entities granted the power of eminent domain. It also provides a clearer definition of “private entity providing public service” in the realm of electricity distribution and transmission, petroleum pipelines, water and wastewater systems, internet and telecommunications, airports, seaports, and irrigation projects.

    And, subject to ownership restrictions under the Constitution, a private entity may acquire private land or patrimonial property for the right-of-way site or location of an infrastructure project, as may be reasonably necessary for the efficient maintenance and operation of the public service pursuant to the private entity’s franchise or authority to operate.

    Moreover, the expansion of the coverage of the law ensures uniform standards in compensation and procedure across both government and private-sector projects delivering public services. It closes the gap previously exploited by some projects that bypassed ROW safeguards through technicalities.

    A significant addition introduced by the bill is the mandatory preparation of a Right-of-Way Action Plan (RAP) by the implementing agency before any property acquisition. This plan must include a census and profile of affected persons, an inventory of affected assets, estimated ROW costs (including compensation for land, structures, improvements, machinery considered as immovables, crops, and trees), a schedule of implementation, institutional arrangements, and proof of stakeholder consultations.

    The RAP is a major leap forward in promoting transparency, accountability, and proper planning. It reduces disputes and strengthens social safeguards, especially for marginalized groups. Similar planning documents are standard in international best practices, such as those recommended by the World Bank and the Asian Development Bank.

    By mandating transparency it builds public confidence, supports media oversight, and allows civil society to monitor compliance.

    Specific Procedures for Ancestral Domains. The ARROW Act introduces a dedicated section addressing the “entry and use of property within ancestral domains”. It mandates securing a “Certification Precondition” from the National Commission on Indigenous Peoples (NCIP). An “Infrastructure Right-of-Way Easement Agreement” is to be executed between the implementing agency and the NCIP-certified indigenous political structure, granting the right to use the land while the ICCs/IPs retain ownership. For ICCs/IPs without an established political structure, the process of “Free and Prior Informed Consent (FPIC)” as per Rep. Act No. 8371 must be observed.

    This harmonizes ROW acquisition with the Indigenous Peoples’ Rights Act (IPRA), balancing infrastructure development with cultural sensitivity. It is a significant improvement from previous vague and often adversarial processes.

    Revised Rules on Negotiated Sale. The rules for negotiated sale will be amended for both government and private entities. The ARROW Act removes the reliance on inconsistent BIR zonal values. The basis for the price offer is now explicitly linked to the standardized property valuation system and schedule of market values established under Rep. Act No. 12001, or the “Real Property Valuation and Assessment Reform Act”.

    This proposed change addresses one of the most common causes of ROW delays: contested compensation. Hence, the standards for assessing the value of property subject to negotiated sale are updated to explicitly include the “APPROVED SMV established under R.A. No. 12001”, or in its absence, the BIR Zonal Valuation. Therefore, a unified valuation framework improves predictability and ensures that compensation reflects true market value, thus reducing litigation and fostering trust.

    The bill specifies the “payment terms” more clearly. Upon the execution of a deed of sale, the property owner shall be paid “seventy percent (70%)” of the negotiated price of the land (exclusive of certain taxes) and “seventy percent (70%)” of the negotiated price of structures, improvements, crops, and trees. The remaining “thirty percent (30%)” shall be paid upon the transfer of title (if wholly affected) or annotation of the deed of sale (if partially affected) and the land is completely cleared.

    Prompt payments incentivize cooperation and reduce friction. Ensuring that informal landholders with decades of possession are recognized and reimbursed aligns with equitable land governance practices.

    There is also a provision regarding the payment of “capital gains tax” by the implementing agency or private entity is now explicitly stated to apply only to the negotiated sale of property classified as “capital assets”. Negotiated sale of property classified as ordinary assets are subject to the existing rules and regulations of the BIR.

    Meanwhile, the buyer of the property will pay for documentary stamp tax, transfer taxes, and registration fees at the Registry of Deeds, for titled lands. Finally, the ARROW Act clarifies the requirements for “untitled lands”, outlining specific documents the possessor shall submit to the implementing agency.

    Modified Guidelines for Expropriation Proceedings. The guidelines for expropriation have also been revised in this manner:

    1. The “initial deposit” to the court in favor of the property owner has been changed to “fifty percent (50%) of the market value of the land”, “seventy percent (70%) of the replacement cost of improvements and structures (including machinery considered as immovable)”, and “seventy percent (70%) of the current market value of crops and trees”. These amounts will be based on the “approved SMV under RA No. 12001”. In its absence, interim measures using BIR zonal valuation and assessed values are provided.
    2. The court is mandated to “immediately issue a writ of possession ex parte” upon compliance with the deposit requirements.
    3. The Act sets a timeframe of “sixty (60) days” from the filing of the expropriation case for the court to determine the just compensation if the owner contests the offered value.
    4. Finally, Court-ordered demolition is now allowed for non-compliant informal settlers.

    These revised guidelines speed up land acquisition while retaining fairness. Fast-tracking possession is critical in projects with firm deadlines, such as flood control or transportation hub corridors, i.e., railroad networks.

    Relocation of Informal Settlers. The responsibility for establishing and developing resettlement sites for informal settlers will be primarily assigned to the Department of Human Settlements and Urban Development (DHSUD), through the appropriate key shelter agency.

    Advance Appropriations. The importance of providing “adequate appropriations in advance” for ROW acquisition for national government infrastructure projects is emphasized by the ARROW Act. Specific expenses to be covered by these appropriations are listed. The Act also clarifies that appropriations for ROW in PPP projects shall follow the guidelines in Rep. Act No. 11966.

    Regulation of Developments within the Declared ROW. The period during which no development contrary to the approved project plans is allowed within the defined right-of-way after the notice of taking is two (2) years. The implementing agency is required to provide the concerned national agencies and LGUs with a copy of the notice of taking.

    Sanctions for Private Entities. The proposed ARROW Act explicitly includes “civil or criminal sanctions” for the president, manager, director, trustee, or responsible officers of a “private entity” who violate any provision of the Act.

    Applicability of Rep. Act No. 8975. The Act explicitly states that the provisions of Republic Act No. 8975 on the prohibition and penal sanction on the issuance of temporary restraining orders, preliminary injunctions, or preliminary mandatory injunctions shall apply. This provision ensures deterrence against non-compliance while protecting the integrity of national priority projects.

    Mandatory Public Disclosure. A new section mandates the “public disclosure of essential right-of-way information” such as the ROW Action Plan, the status of ROW claims, and the status of expropriation cases on the implementing agency or private entity’s website, subject to the Data Privacy Act of 2012.

    Expansion of the IRR Committee. The composition of the committee responsible for preparing the Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) has been updated to include the Secretaries of the Departments of Information and Communications Technology, Environment and Natural Resources, Finance, Justice, Human Settlement and Urban Development, and Agrarian Reform, among other changes.

    A multi-agency approach promotes policy coherence and addresses cross-sectoral challenges such as electrification, connectivity, and environmental safeguards. The participation of DHSUD also ensures the integration of resettlement concerns.

    These reforms under the ARROW Act are intended to address bottlenecks and expedite the acquisition of right-of-way, which is often a critical factor in the timely implementation of infrastructure projects in the Philippines.

    What then are the practical benefits of these proposed amendments? First is faster project execution. The ARROW Act provides clearer procedures, faster court action, and earlier payment schedules to reduce delays in the implementation of critical government infrastructure projects.

    The second is enhanced investor confidence. The PPP proponents will gain from consistent rules and easier access to ROW, meeting important timelines that may lead to cost reductions. Third is fairer compensation. A unified valuation system and clear tax rules reduce conflicts and misunderstandings between all stakeholders in the project. Fourth is better community engagement. The mandatory public consultations and transparent planning process reduce resistance from affected sectors. And finally, inclusive development. Stronger protections for IPs and informal settlers align with constitutional social justice goals.

    In conclusion, the proposed amendments to Rep. Act No. 10752 through the ARROW Act represent a bold and necessary leap toward infrastructure modernization in the Philippines. They reflect a sophisticated understanding of the legal, social, and economic intricacies of land acquisition and signal a commitment to making infrastructure delivery faster, fairer, and more accountable.

    For legal professionals, developers, and policymakers, these amendments are not merely procedural updates – they are strategic enablers of national development. As the Philippines seeks to build resilient, inclusive, and sustainable infrastructure, the ARROW Act provides a sharper legal tool for achieving these goals.

    Share your thoughts in the comments section so we will know if you support or oppose this amendment being pushed by our legislators.

    ——-

    Atty. Jojo is a real estate attorney, an estate planning attorney, a licensed real estate broker, and a PRC-accredited Lecturer/ Speaker for Training Programs in Real Estate. He is a Chartered Trust and Estate Planning (CTEP®) professional who is committed to educating Filipinos about the value and importance of having an estate plan in their lives.

  • The 99-Year Lease Law: Boon for Investments or Threat to Filipino Land Ownership?

    We are only tenants, and shortly the great Landlord will give us notice that our leased has expired.

    – Joseph Jefferson, 19th century American Comedian

    (Part 1 of 2)

    By Realttorney®

    On December 16, 2024, the Senate of the Philippines passed on third and final reading Senate Bill No. 2898. The day after, the House of Representatives passed on third and final reading House Bill No. 10755. Both bills amend Republic Act No. 7652, known as the Investor’s Lease Act. The bicameral conference has not been scheduled at present.

    The passage on 3rd reading by both Houses of Congress of their respective versions of the amendatory bill has ignited significant discussion among stakeholders in the Philippines. SBN 2898 proposes a 99-year lease term for foreign investors, replacing the original 50-year lease term, with a 25-year renewal.

    This development raises crucial questions regarding the potential breach of the constitutional prohibition on foreign ownership of land, its impact on the real estate sector, the negative impact on farmers, plantation workers, including the indigenous cultural communities, and the implications for the government’s land reform program. This part will delve into the specific amendments to the existing law and discuss the seeming evasion of the sacred constitutional prohibition.

    The Philippine Constitution explicitly prohibits foreigners from owning land within the country but allows foreign entities to lease lands under certain conditions. According to civil society groups, the extension to a 99-year lease term in the amendatory bill gives rise to concerns that it circumvents the constitutional prohibition by granting de facto control over land without outright ownership.

    What are the key constitutional and legal considerations that we all need to know to better understand this important piece of legislation?

    Under Section 3, Article XII of the Constitution states, “Alienable lands of the public domain shall be limited to agricultural lands. Private corporations or associations may not hold such alienable lands of the public domain except by lease, for a period not exceeding twenty-five years, renewable for not more than twenty-five years, and not to exceed one thousand hectares in area.”

    The last paragraph of Section 3 declares, “Taking into account the requirements of conservation, ecology, and development, and subject to the requirements of agrarian reform, the Congress shall determine, by law, the size of lands of the public domain which may be acquired, developed, held, or leased and the conditions therefor.”

    The constitutional mandate is quite clear. Section 3, Article XII of the Constitution, explicitly restricts the duration of leases to a maximum of 50 years for alienable lands of the public domain (agricultural lands), and not to exceed 1,000 hectares in area.

    Meanwhile, the coverage of Rep. Act No. 7652, and the recently passed amendatory bills is the granting of long-term lease on private lands to foreign investors for the establishment of industrial estates, factories, assembly or processing plants, agro-industrial enterprises, land development for industrial, or commercial use, tourism, agriculture, agro-forestry, ecological conservation and other similar priority productive endeavors.

    So, what is the difference between alienable lands of the public domain and private lands in the Philippines?

    In the Philippines, alienable lands of the public domain refer to agricultural lands of the public domain that have been reclassified and made available for private ownership, while private lands are those that are not part of the public domain and are privately owned.

    The key difference lies in ownership: public domain lands are owned by the State, while private lands are owned by individuals or corporations. Alienable public lands, once reclassified, become susceptible to private acquisition through various legal means.

    To be sure, a lease of private land to a foreign investor for a reasonable period (25 years initially and extendible to another 25 years before) is valid. The amendment will now allow the aggregate period of the lease contract to extend beyond 50 years but not exceed 99 years.

    It is important to note that only foreign investors who have approved and registered investment under Rep. Act No. 7042 (Foreign Investment Act of 1991, as amended), Rep. Act No. 11534 (Corporate Recovery and Tax Incentives for Enterprises Act) as amended by Rep. Act No. 12066 (CREATE MORE Act), or other applicable laws, or has complied with the investment requirements prescribed by the appropriate Investment Promotion Agency, according to existing laws, can avail of a contract of lease for a period not to exceed 99 years.

    But what if you a foreign investor have no approved and registered investment under the laws mentioned above, but still want to set up shop in the Philippines by renting private lands. What would be the period of lease?

    The law that would govern this case is Pres. Decree No. 471, entitled “Fixing a Maximum Period for the Duration of Leases of Private Lands to Aliens.” Under this law, the maximum period allowable for the duration of leases of private lands to aliens or alien-owned corporations, associations, or entities not qualified to acquire private lands in the Philippines shall be 25 years, renewable for another period of 25 years upon mutual agreement of both lessor and lessee. However, any contract or agreement made or executed in violation of Pres. Decree No. 471 shall be null and void ab initio.

    Our legislators argue that the 99-year lease period will offer stability and predictability to foreign investors who want to invest in the Philippines. And it seems to pass constitutional scrutiny at this time. However, the long-term lease alone is not sufficient to entice foreign direct investments to the country.

    What changes and/or improvements are introduced by the amendatory bills to the Investor’s Lease Act?

    First, the lease contract between the foreign investors and the owners of private lands must be registered with the Registry of Deeds of the Province or City where the lease area is located and annotated on the certificate of title covering the leased area.

    Please take note of the important conditions that must exist in order for the Register of Deeds to register the long-term lease contract: (1) the foreign investor must present proof of an approved and registered investment under the Foreign Investment Act of 1991, as amended, and the CREATE Act, as amended by the CREATE MORE Act; (2) the date of commencement and maximum duration of the lease are certain; (3) the technical description of the property subject of the lease is clearly specified; and (4) there is a provision in the lease contract providing for its termination if the investment project does not commence within 3 years from the signing of the lease contract.

    The last condition is a “safety valve” that ensures that the registered and approved investment enterprise of the foreign investor will definitely push through within the 3-year period from the execution of the lease contract.

    This is apart from the condition that warrants the ipso facto termination of the lease contract upon (1) the withdrawal of the approved and registered investment within the period of the lease contract, or (2) when there is unauthorized use of the lease area for other purposes than what was approved by the Investment Promotion Agency. Moreover, if the ipso facto termination of the lease contract indeed happens then the Lessor has the right to be compensated for the damages that the Lessor may have suffered.

    Moreover, it should be noted that the registration of the long-term lease contract shall be the operative act that renders the lease binding against third persons. As such, registration shall be made following the appropriate provisions of Pres. Decree No. 1529, otherwise known as the Property Registration Decree.

    The second important amendment to know is that the registered long-term lease contract shall not be subject to collateral attack. Hence, it cannot be altered, modified, or canceled except in a direct proceeding in accordance with law. However, this shall be without prejudice to a periodic review of the terms of the lease to be done by the Board of Investments (BOI) or the appropriate Investment Promotion Agency (IPA).

    It should be noted that the continuation of the lease shall be subject to the condition that the lease contract remains equitable for all interest parties – Lessor, Lessee, and the government, as represented by the BOI or IPA. Add to this, is the condition for the renewal of the lease contract upon the foreign investor-lessee, which is the next amendment below.

    The third important amendment is that the foreign investor shall show that that it has made social and economic contributions to the country and the communities in the leased land, as a condition for the renewal or extension of the lease period, which should not exceed 99 years in all.

    Fourth, under the existing law, the leasehold right acquired under the long-term lease contracts may be sold, transferred, or assigned. The amendment now allows that the same leasehold right may serve as security for a loan or as collateral. But when the buyer, transferee, assignee, or creditor is a foreigner or foreign-owned enterprise, the conditions and limitations concerning the use of the leased property as provided under the amendatory law shall continue to apply.

    Fifth, in the case of tourism projects, the lease of private lands by qualified foreign investors shall be limited to projects with an investment of not less than US$ 5,000,000.00, seventy percent of which shall be infused in said project within 3 years from the signing of the lease contract.

    Sixth, in the case of agricultural and agro-forestry lands, the terms of the lease shall be subject to the rules on conversion and the rules of the Department of Agrarian Reform governing Joint Venture Agreements in agro-forestry lands.

    Seventh, unless there is an express prohibition in the lease contract, the Lessee may sublet the leased property with the consent of the Lessor. All the conditions, coverage, and limitations mentioned in the amendatory law shall likewise apply to the sublease contract. Furthermore, the sublease contract shall be registered with the Registry of Deeds and annotated on the certificate of title covering the land, as well.

    Finally, if there is a failure on the part of the foreign investor to initiate the investment project within 3 years from the signing of the long-term lease contract then the contract will be terminated, and all entitlements granted under the law shall be revoked. Thereafter, the Lessor shall be entitled to the possession of the leased property.

    In all, there are adequate safety nets that will protect the owners of private land and balance the interests of the foreign investors and that of the Philippine economy. The amendments ensure that potential inequities or misuse of the leased land are conditions that would terminate the long-term lease.

    In part two of this article, we shall discuss the impact of this proposed legislation on the real estate sector, the impact on farmers, and plantation workers, including the indigenous cultural communities, and the implications for the government’s land reform program.

    ——-

    Atty. Jojo is a real estate attorney, an estate planning attorney, a licensed real estate broker, and a PRC-accredited Lecturer/ Speaker for Training Programs in Real Estate. He is committed to helping new and veteran real estate service practitioners be well-informed of the latest laws, rules, regulations, and information relevant to the real estate service sector.