“[When] the substitution of debtors was made without the consent of [the lender] – a requirement which is indispensable in order to effect a novation of the obligation, [the lender] is therefore not bound to recognize the substitution of debtors.”
– Land Bank of the Philippines v. Ong, G.R. No. 190755 (Nov. 24, 2010)

By Realttorney®
Pasalo is safe only when the seller, the buyer, and the lender all agree. That means a notarized Deed of Sale with Assumption of Mortgage, plus the lender’s written consent to the new borrower. Without that consent, the seller stays the debtor, the mortgage stays on the property, and the buyer can lose both the money and the home.
Below, I explain the rule, the Supreme Court cases behind it, and what buyers and brokers should check before any money changes hands. This article is a further explanation of the Pasalo topic in connection with my CPD lecture on “Understanding Judicial and Extrajudicial Foreclosure of Mortgage and What RESPs Can Do for Their Clients” last October 24, 2026. The legal and tax points were last verified on November 18, 2026.
What is pasalo?
Pasalo is a Filipino term for passing a property, together with its unpaid balance, to someone who agrees to take over the payments. It is not a term in the Civil Code. Legally, a pasalo may be a sale of mortgaged property, an assignment of rights under an installment contract, or the assumption of a loan. The label hides these differences, and the differences decide who is liable to the lender.
Is pasalo legal in the Philippines?
A mortgaged property can lawfully be sold. Article 2130 of the Civil Code voids a stipulation that forbids the owner from alienating mortgaged immovable property. But the sale does not free the property. Under Article 2126, the mortgage subjects the property to the debt, whoever the possessor may be. The Supreme Court has described a mortgage as a real right that follows the property even after later transfers (Garcia v. Villar, G.R. No. 158891, June 27, 2012).
What a new debtor cannot do is to obligate herself to replace the old debtor in the principal obligation, and could not do so in law without the creditor’s consent. Article 1293 allows a new debtor to replace the original one, even without the original debtor’s knowledge or against his will, but never without the creditor’s consent. In Garcia v. Villar, the Court said a buyer of mortgaged property could not take the seller’s place as debtor without the creditor’s consent, so the duty to pay the mortgage debt stayed with the original debtors.
What is a Deed of Sale with Assumption of Mortgage?
It is one document that does two jobs. The seller conveys the property, and the buyer agrees to pay the seller’s remaining loan. It is the right instrument for a pasalo of titled property under a real estate mortgage.
But the paper alone does not change who the lender looks to. The lender’s consent does. Until the lender gives it, the deed is a private arrangement between seller and buyer. My practice recommendation: before entering into this type of contract, secure the lender’s written approval first, because without such consent the entire transaction is bound to fail and complicates matters for the Pasalo parties.
Why does the lender’s consent matter?
In Servicewide Specialists v. Court of Appeals (G.R. No. 116363, December 10, 1999), the Supreme Court treated a sale with assumption of mortgage as equivalent to a substitution of debtors. Notice to the creditor was not enough. The creditor’s consent was always necessary, and without it the sale was not binding on the creditor. That case involved a vehicle under a chattel mortgage. In my reading, the same reasoning applies to real estate loans, because it rests on Article 1293.
Land Bank of the Philippines v. Ong (G.R. No. 190755, November 24, 2010) shows how this plays out. Unable to pay a ₱16-million bank loan, the borrowers sold three mortgaged lots under a Deed of Sale with Assumption of Mortgage. The buyer’s family approached the bank. A branch manager told them there was nothing wrong with the agreement and listed the requirements. She later testified that she had no authority to approve the assumption. The family paid ₱750,000. The bank’s lending center then rejected the application; nobody told the family, and the bank foreclosed.
The Supreme Court held that there was no novation because the bank never consented to the substitution of debtors. The bank was not bound to recognize the buyer as the new debtor. The buyer recovered his ₱750,000 only because the bank had accepted the money and stayed silent, which made it liable for unjust enrichment. That result turned on the bank’s own conduct. A buyer should not count on it.
What happens in an informal pasalo?
Here is an illustrative hypothetical, not a real case. Ana owes a bank ₱1.8 million on her house and lot. Ben pays her ₱500,000 “for the equity” and agrees to pay the monthly amortization. They sign a notarized deed, but nobody asks the bank for its consent. Fourteen months later, Ben loses his job and stops paying.
The bank looks to Ana, the borrower on record, because the debt never moved (Article 1293). It can also proceed against the mortgaged property, whoever occupies it (Articles 2126 and 2129). Ben may claim reimbursement from Ana under their private agreement, but he cannot force the bank to treat him as the borrower.
His ₱500,000 bought a promise from Ana. It did not buy the bank’s recognition or approval.
Can an installment buyer do a pasalo under the Maceda Law?
For real estate sold on installment, including residential condominium units but excluding industrial lots, commercial buildings, and certain sales to tenants, Republic Act No. 6552 (the Maceda Law) protects a buyer who defaults. Section 5 gives that buyer the right to sell or assign his rights to another person, or to reinstate the contract, during the grace period and before actual cancellation. It requires the deed of sale or assignment to be done by notarial act.
Section 5 recognizes the buyer’s right to transfer. In my view, it does not replace the contract to sell. Read the contract’s transfer clause and get the developer’s written approval before anyone pays.
What taxes apply to a pasalo?
A Deed of Sale with Assumption of Mortgage is still a sale. If the property is a capital asset of an individual seller, Section 24(D)(1) of the National Internal Revenue Code imposes a 6% final capital gains tax on the gross selling price or current fair market value, whichever is higher. A statutory exemption, such as the principal-residence rule in Section 24(D)(2), may apply. The deed is also subject to documentary stamp tax under Section 196.
What should buyers and brokers do before paying?
These are my practice recommendations, not statutory requirements.
- Ask the lender, not the seller, for the loan’s status, its balance, and its written requirements for assumption.
- Apply for the lender’s approval first. Do not pay “equity” before approval.
- Get the approval in writing from an officer with authority to give it. A friendly conversation at the branch is not consent.
- Sign a notarized Deed of Sale with Assumption of Mortgage that is expressly subject to that approval.
- Pay the taxes and transfer the title. Brokers and salespersons should not list or arrange a pasalo unless lender consent is part of the plan, and should state plainly what remains unverified.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Is pasalo illegal?
Not by itself. A mortgaged property can be sold, and a clause forbidding the owner from selling it is void under Article 2130. But the debt moves to the buyer only if the lender consents under Article 1293.
Can I simply pay the seller’s monthly amortization?
You can, but the lender is not bound to recognize you. The seller remains the debtor, and the mortgage remains on the property.
Does telling the bank about the sale count as consent?
No. In Servicewide, notice to the creditor was not enough. In Land Bank v. Ong, the family informed the bank, paid ₱750,000, and still had no approval.
Is a notarized deed enough?
A notarized deed documents the agreement between seller and buyer. It does not bind the lender, which must consent separately.
Can the lender refuse?
Yes. Article 1293 requires the creditor’s consent, so a lender is not obliged to accept a new debtor. In Ong, the bank rejected the application.
This article is general information, not legal advice on your transaction. Have a lawyer review the loan, mortgage, and title documents before you sign.
About the Author
Atty. Jojo Perez is a real estate and estate planning attorney, a licensed real estate broker, and a PRC‑accredited lecturer and speaker on real estate topics. Through Realttorney®, he helps property owners, borrowers, and real estate professionals understand the legal principles and practical considerations involved in property ownership, foreclosure, and real estate transactions in the Philippines.

Leave a Reply